Access to Transportation: Bus Network and Spatial Inequality in Columbus

Eungang (Peter) Choi

10/22/2020

Reading

an image

Seoul, Korea

  • Korean War (1950)
  • Massive growth, urbanization
  • Population: 10M (20% of S.Korea’s population)
  • Wider metropolitan area: 25M (48% of S.Korea’s population)

Short Video on Seoul’s growth and Public Transportation

Public Transportation in Seoul

  • 2004 BRT (Bus Rapid Transit) reform
    • bus route redesigns and bus lane expansions
    • frequent network of priority bus lines
    • seamless, free transfers between bus and subway

Result

  • Bus Ridership increased by 14% (2004), and 20% (2010)
  • Bus speeds doubled
  • Faster travel times for cars

More Space for People

  • overpaths and elevated freeways gone
  • more walk paths and nature

Cheonggyecheon

  • 3 mile stretch of elevated freeway built over a stream
  • restored in 2005, uncovering nature
  • less air polution
  • lower temperature in nearby areas during summer
  • “car-oriented city to a human-oriented city”
  • number of fish species 4 -> 25
  • bird species 6 -> 36
  • insect species 15 -> 192

an image

an image

Seoul-ro

  • elevated highway near Seoul Station
  • built in 1970 to accomodate growing traffic congestion in Seoul (1970)
  • Project 7017
    • turn a highway into a pedestrian walkway
    • people-friendly city
    • boost in local economy (connectivity and access to small shops)

an image

an image

Columbus, OH

an image

an image

Research Questions

What is the relationship between the bus network and spatial inequality in Columbus?

  • Income levels
  • Low access (food deserts)
  • Race

Data & Methods

Bus Stop Data

Source: Smart Columbus Data

COTA Bus stop data (Sept. 2018)

  • geocodes
  • bus lines passing through the stop

Create Network

  1. Arrange the stops by each lines
  2. Connect the stops (nodes) in each lines (forming ties)
  3. Calculate Centrality

Centrality

  • Measuring the importance of a node
  • Having the most ties to other actors in the network
  • More access to other parts of the city

Food Access Research Atlas Data

Source: USDA

  • tract-level data on food access (supermarket accessibility)
  • Low income
  • low vehicle access
  • by various demographic groups (race, age)

Key Variables

  • Median Family Income: tract median family income (standardized)
  • Low Access Vehicles: more than 100 households without vehicles & beyond 1/2 mile from supermarket
  • Low Access Population(%): Share of Low Access(1/2 mile) population in tract
  • Low Access Race/Ethnicity(%): Share of Low Access(1/2 mile) in tract population by race/ethnicity
  • WILL BE ADDING URBAN/RURAL VARIABLE

Results

  • WILL BE REPLACED WITH GRAPHS

Results

  • WILL BE MAKING CHANGES

Conclusion

  • Access to transportation is not equally provided to the people that need it most
  • Accordance with the article (“Long Commutes Are Awful, Especially for the Poor”)